2013 D3football.com First Team All-American
2013 USA College Football First Team All-American
2013 Beyond Sports Network Third Team All-American
2014 USA College Football Honorable Mention All-American
Tanner Troutman, a First Team D3Football.com Preseason All-American, finished the 2013 season tied for the national lead with eight interceptions, where he tied Montclair State's Matt Mancino. The First Team D3football.com All-American, First Team All-Middle Atlantic Conference pick and Third Team Beyond Sports Network All-American also finished with 58 tackles, including 0.5 for a loss. The ninth defensive back in program history to earn All-American honors, Troutman earned two D3Football.com Team of the Week and Beyond Sport Network Team of the Week accolades, posting two interceptions in a win over nationally-ranked Delaware Valley and a school-record three against Stevenson. He also broke up six passes on the season, helping him tie for the league lead with 14 passes defended (interceptions plus breakups) en route to earning D3football.com's East Region Defensive Player of the Year honors. Troutman is the second Warrior safety to earn All-American honors from D3football.com since the website split the defensive back slot into cornerback and safety in 2003, joining two-time All-American Ray Bierbach (2010, HM; 2011, 3rd).
Despite battling injuries for much of the first half of 2014, Troutman persevered and ended up picking up his third career all-conference accolades and honorable mention All-American accolades from USA College Football, earning second team honors for the second time after being a first team selection in 2013. The consensus Preseason All-American managed to post 46 tackles, two interceptions and two breakups while playing in just seven games. He is the first three-time all-conference defensive back since Chuck Bellitto was from 2008-10.
