A one-of-a-kind player in both basketball and softball, if it were not for two injuries that prematurely cut short two basketball seasons and one softball season, and the COVID-19 pandemic, there would be no doubt about Kayla Kline's impact as perhaps the best female athlete in school history.
As a junior, she became just the second Warrior to earn first-team all-conference accolades in two different sports in the same season. In softball, she led the MAC Commonwealth in batting average (.469) and slugging percentage (.708) to earn third-team all-region accolades. The Mifflinburg, Pa., native produced the second 25 game hitting-streak of her career, tying her own program-record, while notching multiple hits in 17 games. Kline was named MAC Commonwealth Offensive Player of the Week twice.
In basketball, the 5-8 guard/forward was the lone player in the MAC Commonwealth in the top 10 in the league in points (14.5, fifth), rebounds (9.0, fifth) and assists (2.5, 10th). Her 102 free throws were third in school history, 243 rebounds sixth and 391 points are 12th. She also added 11 double-doubles, the third-most in program history and four 20-point efforts. Kline also earned D3hoops.com Team of the Week honors and MAC Commonwealth Player of the Week honors twice each.
A year later, it looked like Kline was on course to do it again in 2019-20. She averaged 13.9 points and 8.5 rebounds per game for the women's basketball team, sitting comfortably in the top 10 in the league in both categories. She earned D3hoops.com Team of the Week accolades for her play in wins over King's and defending CSAC champion Rosemont. She was named the MVP of Moravian's Tournament after posting 16 points in a win in the championship game of the event, the same game where she became the 12th player in school history to reach 1,000 career points.
However, a torn meniscus ended her basketball career with nine games remaining in the season. Still, in just 79 career games, she finished her career eighth in school history with 587 rebounds, 11th with 1,026 points, 17th with 166 assists and 19th with 39 blocked shots.
Just six weeks later, Kline was the cleanup hitter and shortstop for the softball team. On the opening night of the season, she crushed a homer to center field against Fitchburg State. The next day, she hit a game-tying three run triple in the bottom of the seventh to lead the Warriors to a dramatic win against Norwich. By the end of the week, she was hitting .462 with nine runs, four doubles, a triple, two homers and 12 RBI to go with a gaudy .923 slugging percentage, but the season stopped abruptly due to the COVID-19 pandemic.
Kline finished her career with a school-record .457 career batting average, a .490 on-base percentage and 193 total bases while playing in just 82 games. She is second with 126 career hits and 10 home runs, fifth with 23 doubles and seven triples and sixth with 64 RBI and 73 runs.
She is the only player in the school's history with 1,000 points in basketball and 100 hits in softball. She is the only basketball player to earn two CoSIDA Academic All-District awards and the first to earn three D3Hoops.com Team of the Week accolades. In softball, she set six single-season school records as a freshman and finished her career holding at least 10 school records.
Unsurprisingly, team success followed Kline, as she helped the softball team to a school-record 24 wins in 2017 and helped the women's basketball team to its only appearance in the MAC Commonwealth Championship final in 2019.
The accounting major was also a seven-time member of the MAC Academic Honor Roll, a two-time Academic All-MAC selection, a three-time NFCA Scholar Athlete and a member of Chi Alpha Sigma, the National College Athlete Honor Society.
An auditor with Baker Tilly in Williamsport, (Kline) Zimmerman and husband, Brian, reside in Montoursville. Still active in athletics, she is an assistant softball coach at Montoursville Area High School and has spent the past three seasons on the game operations crew with the Williamsport Crosscutters. She has also helped on game days at Lycoming basketball and field hockey games since her graduation.
Nominated by: Christen Ditzler, former head women's basketball coach